Tuesday, 6 January 2015

When triumphalism trumps thought: A response to Floyd Shivambu

After the debauchery of the festive season, I read Floyd Shivambu's blog on the 1st National Assembly with indifference owing to January worries and other issues. Upon my first reading, what struck me about it was its triumphalist, rhetorical tone, but I choose to not dwell on that. What disturbed me the most was the lazy minded way in which he dealt with theoretical issues. For instance on point (a) as he explains the EFF's ideological posture he sleeps on the wheel and regurgitates the Congress position on South Africa's social formations: which is a mutation of the apartheid project of dividing our people along these lines: Whites, Coloureds, Indians and Blacks i.e Zulu, Xhosa, Pedi etc. This sees him erroneously celebrating the election of so called Coloured and Indian fighters in the CCT, apparently this proves the non-racial nature of the EFF. Anyone who has seriously wrestled with the black consciousness philosophy appreciates that Coloureds and Indians share the same mark of apartheid dehumanisation, so they are included in the Blacks rubric. This explains why Biko and his comrades created an inclusive political identity to mitigate exactly what Shivambu is celebrating. So, the question arises: Commissar Shivambu, why are you celebrating the election of these fighters? Are they not black like all the other blacks elected at CCT level?

The opposite side of this problem is his investment in the non-racialism red herring. The fight was never the fight for a non racialist society, only Whites and their SACP lackeys were obsessed with non-racialism. The fight has always been one against White racism to create a non-racist society. Perhaps I need to explain this further. Racialism is about positively identifying with ones racial grouping: there's nothing sinister there, unless you have uncritically absorbed the poorly conceived congress position on this issue. Non-racism is a different story all together, it's about the complete eradication of white supremacy, the source from which white privilege emerges. So I ask again, why elevate the attainment of a non-racialist society without ridding this society of it's inherent racism? Alternatively, can you have non-racialism in a racist society? Or a 'post racial' racist society? I think you can. History has shown that you can have a society wherein racism operates at the level of the unsaid, even though everyone claims to have non-racialist commitments - South Africa is a case in point. This realisation, sadly awakens me to a depressing conclusion: Our Deputy President has not invested the requisite time to understand the differences between racism and racialism, how embarrassing!! Perhaps Andile Mngxitama's Blacks Can't Be Racist would be a useful starting point.

On point (b) Our newly elected Deputy President floating in the air with triumphalism, proceeds and dwarfs the importance of Biko's philosophy, he says "the black consciousness character is one that appreciate while our people where exploited as a class they were also made to believe through various streams of subjugation and ideological work as Africans they are inferior and the struggle for economic freedom seeks to liberate them from their inferiority consciousness which had been inflicted upon black peoples lives over centuries". This is utter distortion of history! The Black Consciousness Movement( BCM) is and has always been clear that black people were subjugated because of their race not because of class. Class was an offshoot of their racial oppression. Frantz Fanon captures this issue very well when he says "in the colonial world the cause is the effect, you are rich because you are white and you are white because you are rich"; the same is true for blacks, we are poor because we are black not because we are unable to sell our labour power. Even when we do we are kept poor intentionally to keep us at the position of blackness, that is, the lowest rung of humanity. This is a race not a class problem. The inferiority complex he glibly runs to was created by slavery and colonialism which had class connotations, not the other way around as he incorrectly intimates. I would humbly, encourage our Deputy President to go and read Biko and Fanon (if he ever did) again to avoid further embarrassing assertions, in the foreseeable future!

Point (d) is the most glaring example of our Deputy President's theoretical cul de sac. In it, Shivambu bleeds his rigid Marxism, he says, whilst chucking history out the window, "the EFF socialist and internationalist character is expressed in the ideological conviction that ours is a class struggle against capitalism and imperialism and should be guided and underpinned by the principles of international socialist solidarity and common struggles of the exploited masses of the world."

The first question is this: is capitalism a raceless endeavour? Or, put in a simpler way is capitalism without a racial character? If it does, why is this crucial aspect not finding expression on this point? Additionally, does this class struggle the EFF is supposedly engaged in not lose the particular or specific nature of the racist oppression that blacks suffer from in a white supremacist world order? Did the workers in Marikana die because they are workers or because they are black? What about Trayvon Martin, a young Black American boy who lived in a neighbourhood deemed a class bracket above basic blackness? Was George Zimmerman, his racist assailant, thinking class or race stereotypes when he stalked and killed him? Also, is it not a known fact that white workers in Australia doing the same work as those in Marikana earn and live in better conditions? How does the cherished class struggle explain this racial discrepancy? Also what in these common struggles makes us think racism gets elided or removed or lessened in its importance as our leader seems to suggest?

This erasure of race points us to an on-going attempt to remove Fanon from the holy triumvirate of Marx-Lenin-Fanon. After this is achieved, we will be left with a hollowed out Fanon, agreeable to a class obsessed, race-erasing movement that will punt socialism at the expense of the race problematic. A disconcerting development, if ever there was one!

I think here we are dealing with the Congress 'broad church mentality' which accommodated everyone at the expense of race as a governing tool of analysis. This flawed analytical frame was at the root of the "different streams with different parties" situation Shivambu seems to bemoan. The PAC radicals of Sobukhwe's generation walked out of the ANC precisely because of this imposition of rigid Marxist ideas to explain racial oppression. Hence, to posit the EFF as being engaged in a class struggle is to be self deceptive and ahistorical. It misses the point intirely, the fight is and has always been against White Supremacy, class has always been a composite element of that fight. The sooner Shivambu gets this there better, for the chances of economic freedom, or we will rue another missed opportunity!

 

 

Tuesday, 26 August 2014

Requiem for Gaji






I don’t know when I first met Luvuyo “Laganja” Gaji. It might have been at a hearsay influenced meeting at a poetry recital, or was it a drama gathering? Wasn’t it at Moxion (Hip-hop/Kwaito artist) CD launch at the Delft South Taxi Rank in 2006, with me invited to recite my dry angry poetry? But though I’m not sure I’m exact about how he made me feel- after our first talk he left me in an anxiously happy state of being: I was left thinking-“ yeyaphi leoutie?” it’s not like I didn’t know where he stayed in Delft, I had often heard people talking about him- some phrasing him others calling him out. But I was attracted by his love for life, and his masculine effervescence.
Gaji always seemed to be the centre of a group, with a discussion going on or just pure frolicking and goofing around. But there was always a tension in his face betraying an unfulfilled promise. A face tatooed a covenant that overburdened him- an ambitiousness that threatened to sink him. A deep-seated ambitiousness wrestling with the negativity that is ghetto life to hopefully emerge at the other end. Also, Gaji was an innovator by nature. Wasn’t it him who singlehandedly created one of the first drama groups in Delft: namely, Sophumelela Drama And Entertainment Group, with the theme of success being used to name the group?
Wasn’t he a founding member of Rainbow Arts Organisation (R.A.O), with many other cultural activists in Delft? Wasn’t he also intimately involved with the gospel group from Nyanga east called “Bless them all?” Did we not always push him to the forefront when we wanted the community hall from those corrupt anc councillors who held young people’s development with a contempt which always left us deflated, but not Gaji? However, there was a weakness that Gaji suffered from which was borne from his “succeed at all cost mantra” which seemed to dominate his life; that is, the inability to respect history and how we should archive it in our minds as blacks at the margins; for example in an article pasted on the R.A.O offices in Delft, where they are interviewed by the Cape Argus or some other mainstream newspaper, him and Sisa Makaula, in the article in question they erroneously claim they created a group which was created by a collective, I.e. Rainbow Arts Organisation, a gross error if ever there was one! This corruption of history or the correct historical story or narrative would later trickle down to cultural groups like Lingua Franca, where those who started it are erased from its inception and its character is diluted, and a success driven-happy-go-lucky-one-love deep- people movement is created under the guise of professionalisation.











Be that as it may, when I heard Luvuyo “laGanja” Gaji was no more, something in me seemed to seep out and I couldn’t take it back, it was like a broken tap that just won’t or can’t be fixed. I kept crying “what a waste, or God what a waste”, thinking of Gaji as that water that ought to quench the thirst of a thirsty community slowly dying of thirst.  Luvuyo Gaji was the water that brought us to life from the precipice of dehydration; this dehydration emanating from a herculean task of trying to fashion artistic careers in this desolate milieu or desert we find ourselves in Cape Town. As he leaves us with all his imperfections, we are left with a question to whoever is in control of these matters; we ask-“ how do you take Luvuyo whilst we still learning from him, learning not to be “intlama” or fools, learning to dream and be actional towards fulfilling the very dreams that overburdened and left him sombre draining his mellifluous saying, “halala gobongwana” of its symbolical substance, so, God or Qamata as he often called him, how could you impoverish us like this?
 God how could you allow Gaji to escape to the land of our defeated ancestors whilst he has not finished his individual and collective work, that is, the transformation of this society into one that doesn’t demonise black dreams but caresses and affirms them? How could you God?
 This has been the question that dominated my mind since Gaji left us almost two months ago. When this difficult question ambushes me, and I think about it, I’m often left emotional hence my absence from his funeral and nemilaliso, I kept asking myself, how could I face Gaji in that coffin knowing very well that we nowhere close to materialising all those utopian dreams we discussed at his house. How could I be there when I knew his child will never know how it feels to have him say to him or her, “uyintlama, mntanam” or his legendary adage when his surprised or happy- “halala gobongwana!!”
I couldn’t, I hope his family and friends will forgive me!
In 1961, the world famous Algerian/ Martinique revolutionary named Frantz Fanon on his death bed in a country he deemed a land of lynchers (U.S.A), a country, he had reservations about and  didn’t want to go to for hospitalization after he got sick, in a correspondence with Roger Tayeb, his friend, had this to say about death:
“Death is always with us and what matters is not whether we can escape it, but whether we have achieved the maximum for the ideas we have made our own….We are nothing on earth if we are not in the first place the slave of a cause, the cause of the people the cause of justice and liberty”.
Death might have robbed us of Luvuyo Gaji the person, but it has left us with a baton which Gaji dropped on that fateful day. Hence, it is up to us to pick it up and finish the race or to remain crippled by sorrow (something he would have accused us being intlama for if he were alive) or to do what we need to do- which is, to fulfil his mission in the Fanonian sense, and never ever betray it!
Hamba Kahle Mqithi, mna nditshayile okwangoku kwaye ndiyabulela!!!

Halala Gobongwana!!!